IUL and "infinite banking": what the pitch leaves out
The cap is not yours. The insurer can cut it after you buy. One filed contract guarantees it only down to 2%.
A flat year still costs you. The 0% floor stops the index credit, not the charges.
OPM has already written to federal employees calling the FEGLI version of this pitch misleading.
Jump to a section
How the money actually moves
Indexed universal life is permanent life insurance whose cash value earns interest tied to a stock index — usually the S&P 500 — rather than being invested in it. You do not own the index and you do not receive dividends.
The order of operations is the part the sales conversation skips, and it is in the insurers' own filed documents:
- You pay a premium.
- The cost of insurance and the administrative charges come out first.
- Whatever is left goes into an indexed account.
- At the end of the index term, any index gain is multiplied by the participation rate, then capped at the growth cap. If the index fell, you are credited 0%.
So three levers sit between the index and your money: the cap, the participation rate, and in some designs a spread subtracted from the gain. The SEC's bulletin on indexed annuities says these features "can reduce your return in the same way that a direct fee would, even if the annuity is called a 'no fee' annuity."
One more mechanic worth knowing: money taken out of a segment mid-term gets no credit for that term. On a filed product, a partial surrender or even the routine monthly charge deduction taken from a segment before the term ends "will not receive an Index Credit." The charges that come out every month are themselves pulled out before the crediting.
The cap belongs to the insurer
This is the centre of the whole subject, and it is not a matter of opinion. From an insurer's own filed prospectus for a universal life policy with indexed accounts:
- "In certain cases, we may reduce the Growth Cap for a future Index Credit Term for any Indexed Account."
- "We may, at our sole discretion, change the Participation Rate for future Index Credit Terms."
What the contract does guarantee is a floor under those levers — and the floors are nothing like the numbers on an illustration. On that same filed product:
| Lever | Guaranteed worst case |
|---|---|
| Growth cap, account A | No lower than a 2% annual rate |
| Growth cap, account B | No lower than a 1.43% annual rate |
| Participation rate | Never less than 30% |
Read those together. The contract's guaranteed worst case is a 2% cap with 30% participation — and the insurer can move there at its discretion on future terms. Everything above that floor is a current rate the company has chosen for now, and nothing in the illustration obliges it to keep choosing it.
New York's financial regulator requires the specification page of such a policy to state that additional amounts are not guaranteed and that "the insurer has the right to change the amount of interest credited to the policy." FINRA says the same of equity-indexed annuity contracts: some "allow the issuer to change the fees, participation rates and interest caps from time to time," which "could adversely affect your return."
None of this is hidden. It is disclosed in documents nobody reads, in a transaction where the illustration is what gets discussed.
Why "you can't lose money" is wrong
The 0% floor is real. It applies to the index credit. It does not apply to your account value.
In a year the index is flat or down, you are credited nothing — and the cost of insurance, the administrative charge and any rider charges are deducted anyway. The account value goes down. Two sentences from the same filed prospectus sit a few pages apart:
The filing says both things. It does "not credit negative interest to Accumulation Value in a Segment" — and it also describes the policy terminating when there are insufficient amounts to cover the policy charges on the next monthly anniversary, and when a policy loan plus unpaid loan interest exceeds the accumulation value.
Those are not in tension. The floor stops the index from taking money out. The charges take it out anyway.
Cost of insurance rises with age, which is what makes this a long-run problem rather than a bad-year problem. Maryland's insurance regulator puts the universal life version plainly: premiums and cash value "must be enough to pay the cost of insurance and administrative charges," when premiums fall short "the required additional money will be deducted from the cash value," and "the policy will lapse when the cash value is not enough to pay the cost of insurance."
Wisconsin's insurance commissioner went further in a consumer alert, describing what actually happened to people who bought these: "many found that their policies had lapsed (were no longer in effect) with little to no value."
If you already own a universal life policy, you can request a free in-force illustration once a year. Wisconsin's regulator tells consumers so directly. That document shows what the policy is actually on track to do at current rates, rather than what it was projected to do at the rates in force the day you signed. Ask for it every year.
What an illustration is worth
Here is the single most useful sentence in this entire subject, and the insurance industry's own regulators wrote it. Under the NAIC illustrations model regulation — adopted in most states — a basic life insurance illustration must carry this statement:
Required on the illustration itself
"This illustration assumes that the currently illustrated nonguaranteed elements will continue unchanged for all years shown. This is not likely to occur, and actual results may be more or less favorable than those shown."
Not "may not occur". Not likely to occur. That is the regulator's judgment about the document you are being shown.
The same model regulation lists practices that are prohibited, and the list reads like a description of the pitch:
- Do not "state or imply that the payment or amount of non-guaranteed elements is guaranteed."
- Do not "provide an applicant with an incomplete illustration."
- Do not "represent in any way that premium payments will not be required for each year of the policy in order to maintain the illustrated death benefits, unless that is the fact."
- Do not use "the term 'vanish' or 'vanishing premium,' or a similar term that implies the policy becomes paid up."
You are also required to sign an acknowledgement that the non-guaranteed elements "are subject to change and could be either higher or lower," and the producer must certify they "made no statements that are inconsistent with the illustration." If what you were told differs from what the paper says, that signature line is the paper trail.
Where AG 49-A fits
Actuarial Guideline 49 arrived in 2015 because the 1995 illustrations rule said nothing about index features, so two carriers illustrating the same index with the same method could print very different numbers. AG 49-A superseded it for policies sold from 2020, was tightened in 2023, and tightened again for 2026.
What it does: it caps the rate that may be illustrated, it requires an alternate-scale ledger, and — the useful part — it limits illustrated loan arbitrage to 50 basis points. On the alternate scale the loan credited rate may not exceed the illustrated loan rate at all. For policies sold on or after April 1, 2026 it also generally prohibits showing historical index returns alongside the maximum illustrated rate, and requires the statement that historical changes "are not indicative of future returns."
AG 49-A is an illustration rule, not a product rule. It constrains what number an agent may print. It does not cap what the insurer may charge you, does not guarantee any cap or participation rate, and does not make the illustrated figure likely. A policy fully compliant with AG 49-A can still credit you 2%.
"Infinite banking", examined
"Infinite banking", "be your own banker", "bank on yourself" — these are marketing concepts layered on top of an ordinary permanent life policy. They are not products, and they are not regulated terms.
Worth stating plainly, because the absence is itself informative: we could not find a single alert, bulletin or guidance document from the SEC, FINRA, the NAIC, the CFPB or the FTC that addresses "infinite banking" or "be your own banker" by name. No NAIC model, no state product outline and no actuarial guideline contains the phrase. It exists in sales material and almost nowhere else.
The closest a financial regulator has come is California's Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, which warned about people on YouTube claiming individuals can form their own "private banks" and become "individual bankers." The regulator's answer: it does not issue registration numbers for individuals to form private banks, individuals "have not been allowed to form their own private banks for well over a century," and the term "individual banker" has no particular legal significance. That addresses the banking claim, not the insurance product — but it tells you what the phrase is worth.
What a policy loan actually costs
The claim is that you borrow from yourself at no real cost. From a filed policy document:
- The insurer currently charges 3% a year on a fixed-rate policy loan.
- The borrowed portion of your cash value is credited at the loan rate minus 1%.
- After ten years in force, that narrows to the loan rate minus 0.10%.
So borrowing costs you about 1% a year for the first decade, and about a tenth of a percent after that. The spread is the insurer's margin, and the gross rate is a current rate the insurer sets, not a guarantee. It is not free, you are not the bank, and the money is not sitting in a vault with your name on it — it is a loan from the insurer secured against your own policy.
The NAIC closed the door on illustrating this as free money, which is itself the tell: if perpetual positive arbitrage were real, there would be no need for a 50-basis-point cap on showing it.
One honest gap: we could not source a primary-document figure for how many years a policy designed this way runs below the premiums paid before the concept works. What we can source is why it takes years — see the surrender charges below.
The tax bill with no cash behind it
The tax treatment is the strongest genuine feature of these policies, and also where the worst outcome lives.
What is true: growth inside the policy is not taxed as it accrues. The death benefit is generally excluded from the beneficiary's income. And loans from a policy that is not a modified endowment contract "are generally not treated as distributions" — which is the mechanism behind the tax-free-income pitch.
What is also true: if the policy becomes a modified endowment contract, loans are treated as distributions and taxed, plus a 10% additional tax unless you are 59½ or over, disabled, or taking substantially equal periodic payments. A contract becomes a MEC by failing the seven-pay test — paying in more during the first seven years than would have funded the benefits with seven level annual payments. Reduce the benefit in those first seven years and the test is applied retroactively as though the policy had been issued at the lower level. Make a material change and the seven years start again.
The real risk is a loan-heavy policy that lapses. The insurer applies your cash value to clear the loan, and the gain becomes ordinary income. You receive a Form 1099-R. You do not receive any money, because the cash value went to the loan.
Federal courts have upheld this repeatedly — a 2012 Seventh Circuit decision, a 2023 Tax Court summary opinion, and further decisions as recently as 2026 — and the language is unforgiving. In the Seventh Circuit case the taxpayer owed ordinary income tax on $29,093 after a policy was cancelled and the insurer used the cash value to pay off the loans. The court: the cash value of a surrendered policy "whether or not voluntarily surrendered" is includable in gross income, and "it is also irrelevant that no money changed hands." The 2023 decision reached the same result on two lapsed policies, with Forms 1099-R for $13,214 and $5,366, citing the same line of cases. That one is a Summary Opinion, which cannot be cited as precedent — the Seventh Circuit decision is the one carrying weight.
Picture the harm case properly. A retiree in their seventies, drawing "tax-free income" from policy loans for years, stops paying premiums or the charges outrun the value. The policy lapses. A 1099-R arrives in January for tens of thousands of dollars of income, and the asset that would have paid the tax is gone.
If you are a federal employee
Start with the concession, because the pitch contains one true thing: FEGLI is group term insurance and it builds no cash value. You cannot borrow against it. OPM says so. An agent who tells you that is not lying.
And FEGLI Option B genuinely does get expensive. Here is the age curve that explains why fifty-something feds start taking these calls:
| Age | Rate | On $100,000 |
|---|---|---|
| 45–49 | $0.130 | $13.00 |
| 50–54 | $0.217 | $21.70 |
| 55–59 | $0.390 | $39.00 |
| 60–64 | $0.867 | $86.70 |
| 70–74 | $1.863 | $186.30 |
| 80 and over | $6.240 | $624.00 |
The premium more than doubles crossing from the 55–59 band into 60–64. That is a real problem and it deserves a real answer. The question is whether the answer is an indexed universal life policy, or a 20- or 30-year level term policy that solves the same problem with no caps, no participation rates, no surrender charges and no lapse spiral. We ran that comparison separately.
OPM has already written to you about this
In a Benefits Administration Letter on insurance misrepresentations and deceptive sales practices, OPM addressed this marketing directly. Its findings, in substance:
- Marketing that offers to help employees "reduce future FEGLI cost increases" is misleading, because those companies do not offer a FEGLI product and FEGLI premiums are set at government-wide rates — no one can give you a discount on them.
- "OPM has no connection with any other supplemental life insurance products marketed to Federal employees," and OPM does not endorse privately sponsored policies.
- "Neither OPM nor OFEGLI uses sales agents" to administer FEGLI or promote its benefits.
- OPM takes action against improper use of its trademarks, FEGLI included, and asks employees to forward questionable marketing to FEGLI@opm.gov.
If the pitch you are hearing includes the phrase about reducing future FEGLI increases, you are hearing language your own employer's benefits agency has labelled misleading, and there is an address to send it to.
The pattern is documented in enforcement too. In 2017 the SEC charged brokers who it said targeted federal employees nearing retirement with large TSP balances — specifically those 59½ and over — misled them about what they were buying, "even allegedly excluded the words 'variable annuity' from some materials," and "fostered the misleading impression that they were in some way affiliated with or approved by the federal government." Around 200 contracts, about $40 million of face value, roughly $1.7 million in commissions. Those were variable annuities rather than IULs, so take the lesson as the method: implied federal affiliation, TSP-adjacent language, and a focus on people right at retirement.
The TSP match is the line you do not cross
Contribute 5% of basic pay and your agency puts in 5%: 1% automatic, the first 3% matched dollar for dollar, the next 2% matched at 50 cents. And from the FRTIB's own letter to new FERS hires: "If you stop your contributions you are not eligible to receive Agency Matching Contributions."
An agent who needs you to reduce your TSP contribution below 5% to afford the premium is asking you to forfeit up to 4% of basic pay every pay period, permanently. On a $120,000 salary that is $4,800 a year, given away for good — a 100% immediate loss on the first 3% and 50% on the next 2%, with no cap, no cost of insurance and no surrender charge in sight.
There is a second problem with the pitch: the tax-free growth it is built around already exists for you, twice over, without the insurance wrapper.
| Account | 2027 limit |
|---|---|
| TSP elective deferral | $25,500 |
| Catch-up, age 50 and over | $8,500 |
| Catch-up, ages 60 to 63 | $11,750 instead of $8,500 |
| IRA or Roth IRA | $7,500 |
Roth TSP earnings come out tax-free once five years have passed since January 1 of the year of your first Roth contribution and you are 59½ or older. There is no income limit on the Roth TSP, which matters for GS-14 and GS-15 households sitting above the Roth IRA phase-out. One detail to know: all agency contributions go to your traditional balance regardless of where yours go.
So the honest sequence for a federal employee is: capture the full match, fill the Roth or traditional TSP, use an IRA, and only then consider whether you have a need an insurance contract is the right tool for.
When it does fit
Permanent life insurance has genuine uses, and a page that says "never" is not worth reading.
Estate liquidity is the real one — cash to pay estate tax without selling the farm or the business. But look at the threshold before anyone raises it with you: the 2027 federal estate tax basic exclusion is $15,480,000 per person, so roughly $30.96 million of combined exclusion for a married couple. A GS-13, GS-14 or GS-15 household is not in that territory, and neither is almost any military retiree household. If an agent brings up estate taxes in a conversation with a federal employee, treat it as a tell rather than a reason.
The other defensible cases, and this is our own reasoning rather than a regulator's:
- A special needs trust, where a direct inheritance would cost a disabled child their means-tested benefits and a policy payable to the trust would not.
- A business buy-sell agreement, so surviving owners have cash to buy out a deceased partner's share. The tax treatment of this changed with a 2024 Supreme Court decision, so get current advice rather than old advice.
- A high earner who has genuinely run out of room — full TSP deferral, full catch-up, a Roth or backdoor Roth, and still looking for tax-deferred space.
Notice what all three have in common: a specific structural problem that the insurance solves. None of them is "I want a better place to save."
What to demand before you sign
Three documents. Do not accept a summary of any of them.
- The complete illustration, including the guaranteed column. Giving you an incomplete illustration is a prohibited practice, and guaranteed values must be shown and clearly labelled.
- The surrender charge schedule, year by year. On one filed product the charge runs 15 years and can reach about 5.4% of the face amount — roughly $5,400 on a $100,000 policy. Every later increase in face amount starts its own fresh 15-year surrender period on that layer. New York caps the amortization period behind such a charge at twenty years, and its regulator notes that twenty is the maximum rather than necessarily the period in any given contract.
- The policy specifications pages showing the guaranteed maximum cost-of-insurance rates. This is what determines whether the thing survives to age 85.
Then eight questions. The answers in brackets are what the filed documents say, so you will know whether you are being levelled with.
- What is the guaranteed minimum cap and the guaranteed minimum participation rate in this contract? [On one filed product: 1.43% to 2%, and 30%.]
- Can you lower the cap or the participation rate after I buy — and have you done it on policies already in force? [The documents reserve exactly that right.]
- In a year the index is flat, does my account value go up, stay the same, or go down? [Down. Charges continue.]
- What is the surrender charge in year one, year five and year ten? [On one filed product: up to about 5.4% of face, for 15 years, restarting on each increase.]
- What rate do you charge on a policy loan, and what rate is credited on the borrowed value? [On one filed product: 3% currently charged, loan rate minus 1% credited.]
- Does this plan require me to reduce my TSP contribution below 5%? [If yes, stop.]
- Will this be a modified endowment contract, and what happens tax-wise if it lapses with a loan outstanding? [A 1099-R for income you never received.]
- Are you affiliated with, endorsed by, or approved by OPM, the TSP or the VA? [No one is. OPM uses no sales agents.]
One question we cannot give you the answer to: the commission. We could not source a first-year commission percentage for an IUL, or for term, from any primary document — so we are not going to print one. Ask for it in dollars, in writing, alongside what the commission would be on a comparable term policy. An agent who will not answer that has answered it.
Common questions
Can the insurance company lower my cap after I buy the policy?
Yes. Filed policy documents say the insurer may reduce the growth cap for a future index term and may change the participation rate at its sole discretion. The contract guarantees only a floor on those — on one filed product, caps guaranteed no lower than 1.43% to 2%, and a participation rate that may fall to 30%. Nothing in the illustration binds the insurer to anything better.
Does the 0% floor mean I cannot lose money?
No. The 0% floor applies to the index credit, not to your account value. In a flat year you are credited nothing, and the cost of insurance and administrative charges are still deducted — so the account value falls. An insurer's own prospectus says the value can decline to zero and the policy then terminates.
What is Actuarial Guideline 49-A?
It limits what rate an agent may print on an illustration, and caps illustrated loan arbitrage at 50 basis points. It is an illustration rule, not a product rule — it does not cap what the insurer may charge, does not guarantee any cap or participation rate, and does not make the illustrated number likely.
Is "infinite banking" a real product?
No. It is a marketing concept built on top of an ordinary permanent life policy. It is not a product, not a regulated term, and no financial regulator publishes guidance using the phrase. California's financial regulator has separately warned that individuals cannot form their own private banks and that "individual banker" has no legal significance.
Am I really borrowing from myself?
You are borrowing from the insurer against your own cash value, and you pay for it. On one filed product the loan rate is currently 3% while the borrowed value is credited at the loan rate minus 1% — a real cost of about 1% a year, improving to about 0.10% only after the policy has been in force ten years. That spread is the insurer's margin.
What happens tax-wise if the policy lapses with a loan on it?
You can owe income tax with no cash to pay it. When a loan-heavy policy lapses, the insurer applies the cash value to the loan and issues a Form 1099-R for the gain. Federal courts have upheld this repeatedly, holding that it is irrelevant that no money changed hands. In one case the taxpayer owed tax on $29,093 he never received.
Should a federal employee fund an IUL instead of the TSP?
Not before capturing the full match. Contribute 5% of basic pay and your agency adds 5% — 1% automatic, the first 3% matched dollar for dollar, the next 2% at 50 cents. Stop your contributions and the matching stops. Reducing below 5% to pay an insurance premium forfeits up to 4% of basic pay, every pay period, permanently.
Sources
- NAIC — life insurance illustrations model regulation (#582)
- NAIC — Actuarial Guideline XLIX-A
- NAIC — life insurance illustrations, and the AG 49 history
- SEC — investor bulletin on indexed products, caps, participation rates and spreads
- FINRA — issuers may change fees, participation rates and caps
- New York DFS — individual universal life product outline
- Wisconsin OCI — universal life consumer alert and the annual in-force illustration
- Maryland Insurance Administration — universal life
- California DFPI — you cannot form your own private bank
- 26 U.S.C. §7702A — modified endowment contracts and the seven-pay test
- 26 U.S.C. §72 — loans as distributions, and the 10% additional tax
- Brown v. Commissioner (7th Cir. 2012) — tax on a lapsed policy with loans
- OPM — BAL 14-206, FEGLI insurance misrepresentations and deceptive sales practices
- OPM — current FEGLI premium rates
- Federal Register — FEGLI rates effective October 1, 2021
- FRTIB — the TSP agency automatic and matching contributions
- IRS — 2027 retirement contribution limits (IR-2026-136)
- IRS — 2027 estate tax basic exclusion
- SEC — charges against brokers who targeted federal employees with TSP balances
Verified against NAIC model regulations and Actuarial Guideline 49-A, SEC and FINRA investor guidance, insurers' own SEC-filed policy prospectuses, state insurance regulator consumer alerts, the Internal Revenue Code, two federal court decisions, OPM Benefits Administration Letter 14-206 and the FRTIB, on November 14, 2026. Caps, participation rates, loan rates and surrender charges quoted here come from specific filed contracts and are examples of what such terms look like, not market-wide figures — your own policy's numbers will differ and are the only ones that matter. FEGLI rates are those effective the first pay period on or after October 1, 2021; OPM's rate tables are the authority — if a calculator page or a PDF booklet shows something different, go by the tables. TSP, IRA and estate figures are 2027 and change every year. We could not source a first-year commission figure from any primary document and have not printed one. Nothing here is tax or investment advice; we are not licensed advisers.