Medigap with FEHB: why federal retirees almost never need it
Medigap exists to pay the Medicare deductibles and the 20% coinsurance. Most large FEHB plans already waive both once you have Parts A and B. Buying Medigap on top means paying a second premium for coverage you have — and you cannot suspend FEHB to make room for it.
Jump to a section
What Medigap is actually for
Original Medicare leaves gaps. Part A has a per-admission deductible. Part B has an annual deductible and then pays 80%, leaving you the other 20% with no cap. Medigap — Medicare Supplement Insurance — is a standardised private policy sold to fill exactly those holes.
The policies are lettered. Plan G and Plan N are what a newly eligible retiree can buy today; Plans C and F are closed to anyone who became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020.
Plan G covers the Part A and Part B cost-sharing and Part B excess charges, but not the Part B deductible. Plan N is not simply Plan G with copays: it drops the excess-charge coverage and adds a copay of up to $20 for some office visits and up to $50 for an emergency room visit that does not lead to admission.
None of them cover prescription drugs, and none of them pay anything until Medicare has processed the claim.
For a retiree with no employer coverage, this is a reasonable product. For a federal retiree, the question is whether those gaps are still open. Usually they are not.
What your FEHB plan already waives
This is the whole argument, so it is worth being specific. Several of the largest FEHB plans waive their own deductibles, copays and coinsurance for members enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B. In those plans, once Medicare is the primary payor, the FEHB plan picks up most or all of the Medicare deductible, copays and coinsurance on covered medical services.
Two carve-outs matter, and the brochures are explicit about both: prescription drug cost-sharing is not waived, and the plan's own benefit limits still apply — Blue Cross, for one, does not waive the 25-visit cap on home skilled nursing visits. For 2027 GEHA has gone further and removed its reduced drug cost-sharing for members with Medicare primary.
| Plan | How it works |
|---|---|
| Blue Cross Standard | Waives the calendar-year deductible, physician coinsurance and outpatient facility coinsurance |
| Blue Cross Basic | Waives inpatient copays and professional coinsurance, and reimburses part of the Part B premium |
| GEHA High and Standard | Both waive cost-sharing; only High reimburses the Part B premium |
| MHBP Standard | Waives most cost-sharing for members with Medicare A and B |
| Aetna Advantage | Does not waive it — the counter-example |
Read that last row carefully, because it is the reason this page does not say "never". Not every FEHB plan does this. If you are in one that does not, the Medicare gaps are genuinely open and the arithmetic is different.
In the plans that do waive, a Medigap policy would sit third in line behind Medicare and FEHB, with nothing left to pay. You would be buying a product whose claims never pay out.
Waivers are set each plan year and they are not identical across a carrier's options. Before you conclude anything, open your own plan's brochure and look for the section on Medicare — the phrase to find is some version of "we waive cost-sharing for members with Medicare Parts A and B."
One gap is worth checking rather than assuming: foreign travel emergency care. Medigap Plans C, D, F, G, M and N pay 80% of it after a $250 deductible, up to a $50,000 lifetime maximum. Whether that is a gap for you depends on your own FEHB plan's overseas rules, which differ by carrier — read your brochure rather than taking a general claim either way. If you spend months abroad, a travel medical policy is usually cheaper than carrying a whole Medigap premium for it.
The "it's illegal" claim, cleared up
You will read on federal forums that it is illegal for an agent to sell you Medigap while you have FEHB. That is not right, and the detail matters if someone is pressuring you.
The federal anti-duplication rule prohibits knowingly selling a health insurance policy that duplicates Medicare benefits. FEHB is not Medicare. So a Medigap policy sold alongside FEHB does not trip that rule, and an agent who sells you one has not broken the law.
What is true is simpler and more useful: the policy is very likely to be worthless to you, because your FEHB plan has already closed the gaps it was built to fill. "Legal but pointless" is the accurate description, and it is the one to hold onto when the pitch is good.
Why you cannot suspend FEHB for it
Federal retirees have a valuable option: suspend FEHB rather than cancel it, keep the right to come back during a later open season, and in the meantime use other coverage. OPM's own guidance sets out the list of coverage you may suspend for.
Medigap is not on it. The list is Medicare Advantage, TRICARE, TRICARE for Life, CHAMPVA, Medicaid or a similar state programme, and Peace Corps coverage. A Medicare Supplement policy does not qualify.
So the choice is not "suspend and try it". The choice is cancel, and for a retiree cancellation is permanent. You lose FEHB for life, you lose the government contribution with it, and there is no open season route back. A survivor on your enrollment loses it too.
This is the one irreversible decision on the page, and it is the reason to be slow. Compare the right two numbers before you touch it: not your payroll deduction against a Medigap quote, but what you would be giving up — the government's share of your FEHB premium, which runs to several times the monthly difference on most plans — against what the policy would actually pay out on top of a plan that already waives the cost-sharing. And a Medigap policy covers no drugs, so that is a third bill.
The narrow cases where it fits
Two situations, and they are genuinely narrow.
You are already outside FEHB. A survivor on a Self Only enrollment, a former spouse past the end of TCC, someone who cancelled years ago — if FEHB is not on the table, Medigap is a normal product and the usual comparisons apply. The decision here is not FEHB versus Medigap; it is Medigap versus Medicare Advantage versus nothing.
Your FEHB plan does not waive Medicare cost-sharing and you intend to stay in it. Then the 20% is really yours to pay, and a supplement is doing real work. Before buying one, though, price the alternative: switching at open season to a plan that waives cost-sharing is usually cheaper than keeping your plan and adding a second premium.
In both cases, mind the clock. Medigap open enrollment is the six months beginning the first month you have Part B and are 65 or older. Inside that window, an insurer must sell to you and cannot price on your health. Outside it, most states permit medical underwriting — you can be refused, or quoted a figure that reflects your medical history. A federal retiree who keeps FEHB at 65 and considers Medigap at 72 is shopping under underwriting, which is a different market entirely.
Both halves of that rule matter. A disability retiree who went on Medicare before 65 does not get the window when Part B starts — it opens at 65.
The comparison worth your time
The real money for a federal retiree at 65 is not in Medigap. It is in whether to take Part B at all, and what your FEHB plan gives you for carrying it.
Part B costs $202.90 a month with a $283 annual deductible for 2026. The 2027 figures had not been published when this page was updated; CMS normally releases them in mid-November, so check for the new ones before relying on these. Higher incomes pay an income-related surcharge on top.
Against that, several plans reimburse part of the premium for 2027:
| Plan | Annual giveback |
|---|---|
| Blue Cross Basic | $800 |
| GEHA High | Up to $1,000 |
| MHBP, via its Aetna Medicare plan | $900 |
A giveback of $800 against a premium of about $2,435 a year does not make Part B free, but it changes the calculation materially — and it is a decision with its own permanent edge, because the late enrollment penalty for Part B is 10% for every full year you could have had it and did not, charged for as long as you have Part B.
That is the comparison to spend an evening on. Medigap is a side road.
If an agent is pitching you
Federal retirees are a known market, and the pitch is usually accurate about Medicare and silent about FEHB. Four questions sort it out quickly:
- Which of my FEHB plan's cost-sharing does this policy pay that my plan does not already waive? If the answer is vague, there is nothing.
- Can I suspend FEHB for this? The answer is no. An agent who says yes is wrong, and that tells you what the rest of the conversation is worth.
- Am I being asked to cancel FEHB? If so, stop. That one is permanent.
- What happens to my prescription coverage? Medigap covers no drugs at all.
There is no deadline pressure here that is real. Open season comes round every year; Medigap underwriting rules do not change because you took a week to think.
Common questions
Is it illegal to sell me Medigap when I have FEHB?
No. The federal anti-duplication law bars selling a policy that duplicates Medicare, and FEHB is not Medicare, so an agent can legally sell you a Medigap policy alongside it. The problem is not legality. It is that you would be paying twice for the same coverage.
What does Medigap actually cover that FEHB does not?
For most of the large FEHB plans in 2027, almost nothing. Medigap exists to pay the Part A and Part B deductibles and the 20% Part B coinsurance, and plans like Blue Cross Standard and Basic, GEHA and MHBP already waive those for members with Medicare Parts A and B. The exception is foreign travel emergency care, which some Medigap plans cover and which FEHB plans handle differently.
Can I suspend my FEHB to try Medigap?
No. FEHB can be suspended for a Medicare Advantage plan, TRICARE, CHAMPVA, Medicaid or Peace Corps coverage — never for a Medigap policy. If you want Medigap instead of FEHB you have to cancel, and for a retiree cancelling is permanent.
What happens if I cancel FEHB and change my mind?
You cannot get it back. A retiree who cancels FEHB loses it for life, and the government contribution with it. There is no open season route back in. Suspension is reversible; cancellation is not.
Is there any case where Medigap makes sense for a federal retiree?
It can, if you have already decided to leave FEHB entirely — for example a survivor without an FEHB-eligible enrollment — or if you are in an FEHB plan that does not waive the Medicare cost-sharing and you intend to stay in it. Both are narrow. Neither is a reason to drop FEHB to buy it.
When is my Medigap open enrollment period?
Six months beginning the first month you have Part B and are 65 or older. During that window an insurer must sell to you regardless of health. After it closes, most states allow medical underwriting, which means you can be refused or charged more. A disability retiree on Medicare before 65 gets the window at 65, not when Part B starts.
What should I compare instead?
The Part B premium against what your FEHB plan gives back for carrying Part B. Several 2027 plans reimburse part of it — Blue Cross Basic at $800 a year, GEHA High up to $1,000. That comparison decides far more money than a Medigap policy would.
Sources
- OPM — FEHB and Medicare
- OPM — Medicare vs FEHB enrollment (RI 79-9)
- Medicare.gov — Medigap basics and plan letters
- Medicare.gov — Part B premium and deductible
- Social Security Act §1882 — anti-duplication provisions
- 2027 Blue Cross Blue Shield FEHB brochure (RI 71-005)
- 2027 GEHA FEHB brochure (RI 71-006)
- 2027 MHBP FEHB brochure (RI 71-007)
- 2027 Aetna Advantage FEHB brochure (RI 73-906)
- OPM — cost of insurance and the government contribution formula
Plan waivers and Part B reimbursements verified plan by plan against the 2027 FEHB brochures (RI 71-005, 71-006, 71-007, 73-906); suspension rules against OPM RI 79-9; the duplication rule against 42 U.S.C. 1395ss; Medigap plan details against the CMS Choosing a Medigap Policy guide. November 13, 2026. Part B figures are 2026; the 2027 figures were not yet published and are normally released by CMS in mid-November. Figures are FEHB non-postal — PSHB plans for postal retirees have their own Medicare rules. Verify details in your own plan's brochure before deciding.